Friday, 2 October 2026

Friday Five: Books Read in September

  1. Lords and Ladies by Terry Pratchett (Corgi Books) - In which we learn that elves are nasty creatures who deceive humans with glamour and can be conjured by dancing near standing stones, preferrably under the influence of strong cider. Their strength lies in making others think they are weak, and they can be defeated by iron. "They were a merry folk, especially when they were twisting your arm to see how far it could go." Terry Pratchett's fourteenth Discword novel is one of the witches ones with elements of A Midsummer Night's Dream and various other allusions to folktales and rural myths. Granny defends the Tooth Fairy - "Very hard-working woman, I'll never know how she manages with the ladder and everything" - although she is less complimentary about unicorns, and no one has a good word to say about folk music. Although she preferred him when he was a court jester, Magrat is about to marry the king, Verence, while the other witches are trying to offer honeymoon advice. Her impending power angers the elf queen who takes her on, without realising she must deal with the whole coven, during which battle Granny (who can 'borrow' the minds of animals) shifts her mind into the consciousness of a hive of bees with one single thought - save the queen. It is as rich, complex and amusing as ever with all the asides and cultural considerations one expects from Terry Pratchett, including the grouan-inducing puns in the footnotes: "Then she raised her hat and carefully liftes down a bowl of cream, custard and jelly which she had secreted there. (Nanny Ogg was also a great picker-up on unconsidered trifles.)"
  2. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin (Vintage) - The decade-spanning friendship of Sam and Sadie is based on gaming culture in which if you don't take risks and choose alternatives, "you'd be stuck in the first part of the game forever." Sam and Sadie knew each other as children and after breaking off their childhood friendship, they meet again before a Magic Eye poster in a train station, implying that illusions and images can create new beginnings. They creat a game, Ichigo, in which a young child is lost in a storm and must make their way home in a floating world inspired by the Japanese woodblock print of The Great Wave off Kanagawa by Katsushika Hokusai. It is a homecoming story but also a language story. "How do we communicate in a world when we don't have language?" The novel addresses issues of cultural appropriation and multi-dimensional expression in which there are infinite possibilities. Sadie travels to the Nezzue Shrine in Tokyo, which has a tunnel of red torii gates for visitors to pass through. "Life was always arriving. There was always another gate to pass thrugh. (Until of course, there wasn't.)" There are similarities with Herman Hesse's The Glass Bead Game in its suggestion that there are rules to work out in winning at the game of life, but through the many detailed virtual worlds created in this novel, the real world is always waiting. "Winning is accepting there are some races a person cannot win." With both popular and critical acclaim, this is a contender for top 100 books of the twenty-first century.
  3. Standing Heavy by GauZ' (Maclehose Press) - Shortlisted for the International Booker Prize 2023 and set in Paris, this novel follows undocumented residents vying for jobs. The title refers to security guards who observe people and their habits every day. Many of the chapters are short vignettes which read like poetry as they explain life in a department store and the customers who shop for luxury items and worship at the capitalist altar on the Champs Elysses. As people purchase leopard print clothes and accessories, the author notes the irony of the perfect camouflage for the jungle being "used to attract as much attention as possible in the city." The plight of these men (and they are all men) who have risked everything to end up in "this filthy, ramshackle, tumbledown overcrowded hellhole on the heart of the French capital" is documented without sentimentality. They remain inscrutable despite their conflicting motivations, as the security guard occasionally questions the ethical politics of his role. "What great moral imperative is satisfied by pursuing a perfume thief? How absurd is it to hunt down a man who has stolen from Bernar, the richest person in France, a frivolous frippery made by Liliane, the seventh richest? What zeal! What a preposterous lack of objectivity and judgement!" At only 167 pages, this small book has a lot of weight and its poignant musings pack a hefty punch.
  4. Cheating the Hangman by Judith Cutler (Allison and Busby) - The Reverend Tobias Campion is the first-person narrator of this cosy historic murder mystery, set in the Regency period of early 1800s England. This is number three in the series, and the author says that although she would have loved to write, “a pseudo-Georgette Heyer confection set in Bath or Brighton”, she felt her character insisted upon, “an unfashionable parish somewhere in the Midlands”. While there is little action, Cutler makes much social commentary, adroitly embracing the historical setting and language. When Rev Campion encounters a dead body on Easter Sunday, the fact that the corpse is nailed to a tree in crucifix position, leads him to attempt to solve the crime in case it is an attack on all clergymen. Campion manages to embody Christian goodness without being an insufferable prig, which is quite an accomplishment on the author’s part. He is eager to help the community and do God’s work, “whether one is seen doing it or not”. Both Rev Campion and his friend Dr Toone, a medical professional who provides postmortems, are disgusted by landlords and other authority figures who don’t care for their tenants or parishioners. Campion often consults with women, particularly Maria (wife of Dr Edmund Hansard, the village doctor) and doesn’t dismiss them out of hand, unlike many of his contemporaries. There is a modern approach to medicine, some interesting period-relevant language, and a collection of comfortable characters in whose company I would willingly spend more time. 
  5. The Burrow by Melanie Cheng (Text Publishing) - Novels about the death of a child are bleak and navel-gazing by necessity. However sparse the prose and contained the narrative, they may be quick to read but never easy. Despite occasionally reading like a creative writing exercise, Melanie Cheng’s work has great inner depth but little external appeal. May and Jin are raising their daughter, Lucie, after their youngest daughter, Ruby, drowned in a bathtub. They are all silo-ed in their grief. May has anger issues, Jin succumbs to cliché and a work-place affair, and Lucie imagines nightmarish scenarios of the people around her dying horrendously. When Lucie requests a pet, the psychiatrists believe it might help with their grief, so the family introduce a rabbit to their household. The innocent, twitching, perpetually moving prey animal has a lot of feelings to absorb. “Perhaps this was the purpose of all pets, to provide a buffer between humans who had forgotten how to talk to one another.” Because this is set in Melbourne in the early 2020s, ‘the world’s most locked-down city during the pandemic’, there are extra issues of isolation, from the constant wearing of surgical masks, to the inability to travel with a loved one in an ambulance, or the necessity of placing oneself in quarantine when suspected infectious contact has been made, coupled with a “paradoxical sense of freedom in not having to make all the decisions for once.” When May’s estranged mother, Pauline, has a fall, the physiotherapists won’t let her return home but can’t keep her in hospital, so she is discharged into May and Jin’s care and sets up in the granny flat, which is blissfully brand-new. Pauline forms a bond with Lucie through looking after the rabbit and reading Watership Down, with all the inappropriate associations of reading such a novel to a sensitive ten-year-old. The rabbit, naturally named Fiver, becomes one of the main protagonists in the story, which is told from all five of the characters’ perspective. Through May, the author highlights the mundanity of parenting, and its hypocrisy. “The entire ecosystem depended on people caring what other parents thought of them. Why else would they bake the cakes and fry the sausages and volunteer at the school fete?” Everyone’s grief is unique, intense and profoundly personal. It is also exhausting and uninteresting to those outside the circle. The novel evokes compassion and heartache, but little enjoyment or catharsis.

No comments: