Showing posts with label poverty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label poverty. Show all posts

Tuesday, 25 August 2026

Hogarth’s House


Some time ago (last year) when we were in England, I visited Hogarth's House in Chiswick. This house, built between 1713 and 1717 was the home of William Hogarth, painter, engraver and satirist from 1749 until his death in 1764. In 1900, the House was put up for sale for re-development. A preservation campaign by artists and writers could not raise the purchase price but Lieutenant-Colonel Shipway of Grove House in Chiswick bought and restored it, opening it to visitors from 1904. The House survived serious war-time damage in 1940 and a fire in 2009; a careful refurbishment was completed in 2011. For most of its life, Hogarth's House has displayed a collection of Hogarth's prints.


A statue of Hogarth was commissioned for the Millennium by the Chiswick Traders Association. This was the model which was submitted by Jim Mathieson, the sculptor who won the commission. It was completed in a modified form, with the addition of a pug dog at the artist's heels, and has become a local landmark. The statue was unveiled by Ian Hislop and David Hockney in 2001.

Maquette for Hogarth sculpture, 1999, by Jim Mathieson
Hogarth is remembered today as the 'Father of British Painting'. He hated injustice and would use his art to draw attention to the issues he cared about. Hogarth highlighted not only poverty but political corruption, moral depravity and cruelty to animals. he was also active in tackling the issues he hated about serving as a founder Governor of the Foundling Hospital and producing two of his most famous works, Beer Street and Gin Lane as part of a campaign to reform laws on gin production. Hogarth was also involved in promoting the first copyright legislation for artists in 1735.

The Distrest Poet, 1737
In an untidy garret the poet in his dressing gown works on a poem entitled Riches - the milkmaid confronts his wife, who is darning a pile of clothes, at the door holding a lengthy tally of their debts and demanding payment. The baby in the bed is crying, the cat is nursing kittens, and the dog eats the meat from a plate on a chair. Above the poet's head a map labelled A View of the Gold Mines in Peru suggests his unrealistic dreams of wealth. Meanwhile, indications such as his pipe and tobacco on the window sill, the mug of ale on the chair in the back of the room, the lace cuffs drying by the fire, his ill-fitting wig, and gentleman's sword lying at his feet may point to his self-interest and refusal to deny himself personal pleasures.

The Enraged Musician, 1741
In 1740 Hogarth advertised The Enraged Musician as a companion to The Distrest Poet. The scene may be near St Martin's-in-the-Fields. The musician at an open window is covering his ears against the typical noises of the street. A ballad-seller chants, her baby cries, a milkmaid and other street-traders cry their wares, a small boy plays a drum and another urinates under the startled gaze of a small girl with a rattle, an itinerant oboist plays, a knife grinder sharpens a cleaver, and cats screech on a roof. This is ostensibly a comic scene as the violinist attempts to rehearse while the noisiest inhabitants of London pass by his window.
Some of the Principal Inhabitants of the Moon, as They Were Perfectly Discovered by a Telescope, 1745
The circular form of the print is designed to suggest the field of vision offered by a telescope. On an elevated structure sits a king bearing a sceptre and orb, he has a coin for a head. A bishop is resting his limbs on a luxurious plie of cushions; his head, a Jew's harp, operates a money-making machine by means of a prayerbook tied to a crank. The machine, shaped like a church steeple, is topped by a weather vane, which like the moons on the king's orb and sceptre, is a symbol of inconstancy.

Emblematic Print on the South Sea Scheme, 1721
This print caricatures the financial speculation, corrupton and credulity that caused the South Sea Bubble in England in 1720-1721. After the South Sea Company's shares rose rapidly in price from around £100 to over £1,000, many investors were ruined when the bubble burst and the value of stock in the South Sea Company crashed. Political scandal ensued when fraud among the company's directors and corruption of cabinet ministers became clear. 

The print shows a London scene, with the Guildhall and its monumental statue of the giant Gog (or Magog) to the left, a classical column based on The Monument to the Great Fire of London to the right, and the dome of St Paul's Cathedral rising behind the buildings in the background. The base of the column bears an inscription which reads, 'This Monument was erected in memory of the destruction of this city by the South Sea in 1720,' while foxes fight above. It is deliberate that the monument, a symbol of the City's greed, dwarfs St Paul's, a symbol of Christian charity.

The centre of the print is dominated by a financial wheel of fortune, ridden by stock figures including a whore, a clergyman, a housewife, a hunchback and a Scottish nobleman on a fat-faced horse. To the front of the crowd a short pickpocket (representing Alexander Pope who profited from the scheme) rifles through the pockets of a larger gentleman (possibly John Gay who lost his investment and all his imagined profits). Women line a balcony to the upper left, queuing to enter a building surmounted by stag's antlers, under a sign which offers 'Raffleing for Husbands with Lottery Fortunes in Here.'

To the left, a blindfolded Fortune hangs by her hair from the balcony of the Guildhall while a winged devil cuts off parts of her body with a sycthe and throws the bloody chunks into the baying crowd. In the bottom left corner, distinctive clothing identifies a Catholic, a Jew and a Puritan, who are ignoring the tumultuous scene to concentrate on their game of chance. To their right, the naked figure of Honesty is broken on the wheel by Self-interest while an Anglican priest looks on. Further right, Villainy - who has removed his fair mask which now hangs upside down between his legs - scourges Honour beneath the column. Standing nearby is a monkey (a symbol of mimicry or 'aping') who wears a gntleman's sword and a baronial hat, and wraps himself in Honour's cloak. In the lower right corner, the figure of Trade lies asleep or dead, ignored by all. 

The Weighing House, 1763
Frontispiece to John Clubbe's Physiognomy: being a sketch only of a larger work upon the same plan, this features a scene outside an inn with the sign of 'The Weighing House', with nine men being assessed along a scale of gravity to levity. At right a man by the inn door operates a pulley to raise a magnet from the crossbeam of the inn sign; the men are blanced in a semi-circle from 'A', ''absolute Gravity', standing on his head to 'I', 'absolute Levity or Stark Fool' in the middle of the air, just beneath the magnet. At the centre, horizontally balanced and with a nonchalant expression, is E 'good Sence'.

The Shrimp Girl
The work depicts a woman selling shellfish on the streets of London, typically a job for the wives and daughters of fishmongers who owned stalls in markets such as Billingsgate. The subject balances a large basket on her head, bearing shrimps and mussels, together with a half-pint pewter pot as a measure. Its size suggests that it was intended as a portrait, rather than a sketch for a larger work. 

The Battle of the Pictures and Satire on False Perspective
In February 1745, Hogarth auctioned many of the oil paintings on which his prints had been based. Bidding at the auction was by ticket, as usual decorated with a witty Hogarth picture. Here historic paintings are shown marching into battle with Hogarth's works.

Satire on False Perspective was produced by Hogarth in 1735 for his friend John Joshua Kirby's Pamphlet on perspective in art. In the subtitle Hogarth remarks, 'Whoever makes a design without the knowledge of perspective will be liable to such absurdities as are shewn in this frontispiece.' There are some great errors, such as the sign being overlapped by distant trees, both ends of the church being visible at the same time, and the obvious difference in size of various people and animals. On the whole, it offers an Escher-like array of impossible lines and vanishing points. 

The Politician
First published in 1775 after Hogarth's death by Mrs Jane Hogarth, it is reported that the subject of The Politician is Hogarth's shortsighted friend, Ebenezer Forrest. A lacemaker and politician, Forrest is here portrayed reading his newspaper while he inadvertently sets fire to his hat.

Columbus Breaking the Egg, 1972
Issued as a subscription ticket for his treatise on art, The Analysis of Beauty, this engraving depicts an apocryphal tale (the 'Egg of Columbus') concerning Christopher Columbus's response to the dectractors of his discovery of the New World. The story goes that at a meal, several men began to comment that any number of other people could have found their way to the New World and that Columbus's feat was unremarkable because of its simplicity. Columbus replied that it was only easy now that he had demonstrated how it was done, and by way of an example, he challenged anyone present to stand an egg on its end. After all those attempting the feat had admitted defeat, Columbus demonstrated the simplicity of the challenge by crushing one end of the egg against the table which allowed it to remain upright.

The print shows Columbus having just demonstrated the method for making the egg stay upright. His audience look on in amazement and one man behind him beats his forehead in frustration at the simplicity of the solution. At either end of the table are men caught still in the act of attempting to balance the eggs.

Hogarth uses the story as a parallel to what he considered his own discoveries in art. He expected much the same reaction to his book as Columbus had received. Hogarth considered that he too had discovered a 'New World', but one with the sphere of art rather than geography, and just as Columbus's detractors had mocked the navigator's accomplishment as simple and inevitable, Hogarth expected the art connoisseurs to mock his thesis on the serpentine 'Line of Beauty' as self-evident and unimaginative.

To strengthen the connection between himself and the Columbus of the tale, he included two eels in a bowl in the centre of the table, their bodies demonstrating the 'Line of Beauty' as they coiled around a pair of eggs. To further underline the ironic nature of the print, the composition is based on Da Vinci's The Last Supper, with the bowl containing the eggs and the eels replacing the Host.

A Modern Midnight Conversation
Hogarth may have decided to publish this print (which is based on a painting of about a year before) in response to the hubbub in London against a new excise tax being proposed on liquor and tobacco. This satire, where drunken excess is ironically called 'Modern Conversation' was enormously popular and was pirated by other printmakers as well as being reproduced on fans, snuffboxes, and tankards. 

The clock indicates four in the morning and eleven men are shown around a table in different stages of drunkeness, having gathered at midnight. A punchbowl decorated with Chinese figures appears at the centre of the table, and empty bottles piled on the floor and mantlepiece testify to many rounds of punch consumed, as does the overflowing chamber pot at lower right.

Though the print's caption claims that it contains no portraits, this may be disingenous since the people in the print are variously guessed at. The parson ladling punch is often identified as the Reverend Ford or Orator Henley, and the man on the floor is believed to be bare-knuckle boxer James Figg. Some critics even contend that the likeness of the man seated in the left of the picture and staring directly at the viewer with a bored and grumpy expression is a self-portrait of Hogarth.

Strolling Actresses Dressing in a Barn, 1738
A travelling company of nine actresses and four child actors, all dressed as classical deities, prepare to perform at the George Inn. The troupe are preparing for the play The Devil to Pay in Heaven, a fiction that was probably intended as a satire on the mystery plays which were heavily controlled by the church. Hogarth contrasts the roles of gods and goddesses that appear in the play with the mortal reality at every turn. The leaky, draughty barn stands in for the heavens in which they will shortly be play acting. The bill on the bed introduces the cast and aids the viewer in identifying the figures portrayed: Diana, Flora, Night, Siren, Aurora, Eagle, Cupid, two Devils, a Ghost and attendants.

Diana, identifiable by her crescent moon headdress, takes centre stage in the print, practising her pose. She imitates the Diana of Versailles, but she looks foolish as she has neither quivers nor arrows. Her hooped petticoat has fallen to her feet, exposing her thighs, and the low neckline of her shirt reveals her breats; she is anything but the chaste goddess. She acknowledges the attention of the viewer with a slight smile. To her left Flora is dusting her hair with a flour shaker in front of a broken mirror propped up by a candle, in an effort to prepare herself for the role of the fertility goddess.

Cupid 'floats' above then with the aid of a ladder, fetching two stockings for Apollo, identifiable from the sun on his head, who points out with the aid of a bow their hanging place on a cloud beneath a dragon. Next to the actress playing Diana, two children dressed as devils help themselves to a mug of beer left on the altar like a sacrifice. A woman next to them is shocked by their behaviour but she has her hands full assisting the 'ghost' to bleed a cat from its tail ( due to an old wives' tale that condoned animal cruelty as a cure for human ailments).

Above the women in this corner, a face peers down through the opening in the barn roof. Here a low mortal looks down on the gods from heaven, rather than the other way round. He fills the role of Actaeon, who accidentally saw Diana naked and was changed into a stag and torn apart by his own hounds as punishment. Here though the viewing of Diana is intentional. In the right foreground Juno practises her lines, while Night (star-spangled headdress) darns a hole in her stocking.

In front of Night and Juno is Hogarth's take on a vanitas, but here the symbols of death are replaced by comic figures; a monkey wearing a cloak urinates into a helmet; one kitten plays with an orb while another plays with a lyre. The animals presumably fill the roles of attendants mentioned in the playbill; their play acting as human serves to highlight further the discrepancy between acting and reality.

To the left of the picture, Ganymede, who is not yet fully dressed, accepts a drink of gin to ease the stabbing pain of his toothache from the Siren, who is being attended to by Aurora (morning star on her headdress). In the foreground a woman costumed as Jove's eagle feeds her child; the food rests on a crown with a small folded paper bearing the title The Act against Strolling Players. Next to her, Ganymede's breeches lie on the small bed adjacent to the playbill, which is slipping perilously close to the chamberpot.

It would be their last performance before the 1737 Licensing Act cracked down on theatres, closing all but Drury Lane and Covent Garden. The Act was brought in as a result of John Gay's Beggar's Opera of 1728, which had linked Robert Walpole with the notorious criminal Johnathan Wild. Henceforth, all new plays had to be approved by the Lord Chamberlain and all non-patent theatres were closed.

A Chorus of Singers
Hogarth first used this image as a subscription ticket but later issued it as one of a set of Four Groups of Heads along with The Laughing Audience, Scholars at a Lecture, and The Company of Undertakers. The choir is rehearsing Judith, an oratorio by Hogarth's friend William Huggins, but they are ignoring the conductor, despite him being so animated that he has lost his wig. Hogarth contrasts the groups of singers - cherubic shool boy sopranos, cheerful altos, labouring tenors and pained bass singers. 

The Laughing Audience
Hogarth painted Southwark Fair and The Rake's Progress and advertised the prints together. He used The Laughing Audience as the subscription ticket. He issued The Fair in 1734 but delayed selling The Rake's Progress until it was portected by the new copyright law for which he had campaigned.

The Laughing Audience shows three different groups - the earnest orchestra playing in the pit, the common audience enjoying the performance and foppish gents paying more attention to the orange girls than the play.

The Heir and The Levee
A Rake's Progress is probably Hogarth's most famous work. The series of eight paintings were produced in 1732-1734, then engraved in 1734 and published in print form in 1735. The series shows the decline and fall of Tom Rakewell, the spendthrift son and heir of a rich merchant who comes to London, wastes all his money on luxurious living, prostitutes and gambling, and as a consequence is imprisoned in the Fleet Prison (a debtor's prison) and ultimately Bethlem Hospital (Bedlam).

In the first print, The Heir, Tom has come into his fortune on the death of his miserly father. While the servants mourn, he is measured for new clothes. Although he has had a common-law marriage with her, he now rejects the hand of his pregnant fincee, Sarah Young, whom he had promised to marry. She holds his ring and her mother holds his love letters. He pays her off with a handful of coins while behind him, the administrator of the estate steals a coin from the money bag.

Evidence of the father's miserliness abounds: his portrait above the fireplace shows him counting money; symbols of hospitality (a roasting jack and a spit) have been locked up at upper left; the coat of arms shows three clamped vises with the motto 'Beware'; a half-starved cat reveals the father kept little food in the house; while a stack of ashes in the fireplace demonstrates that he spent even less money on wood to heat his home. A servant hanging mourning crepe accidentally uncovers a cache of gold coins, and there is evidence that the father went so far as to resole his shoes with a piece of leather cut from a Bible cover.

The second image shows Tom at his morning levee in his new London home, attended by musicians and other hangers on, all dressed in expensive costumes. Surrounding Tom from left to right: a music master at a harpsichord; a fencing master; a quarterstaff instructor (possibly James Figg); a dancing master with a violin; a landscape gardener; an ex-soldier offering to be a bodyguard; and a bugler of a fox hunt club. The quarterstaff instructor looks disapprovingly on both the fencing and dancing masters. Both masters appear to be in the 'French' style, which was a subject Hogarth loathed. At lower right is a jockey with a silver trophy showing Tom's racehorse, 'Silly Tom'. 

In the background left are more hangers-on including a poet, a wig maker and a hat maker. Upon the wall, between paintings of roosters (emblems of cockfighting), there is a painting of the Judgement of Paris.

Six of the eight prints of A Rake's Progress
The third print, The Orgy, depicts a wild party at a brothel, where prostitutes are stealing Tom's watch, and several of them have black spots on their faces to cover syphilitic sores. In the fourth, The Arrest, Tom narrowly escapes arrest for debt by Welsh bailiffs (as signified by the leeks in their hats) as he travels in a sedan chair. He is saved by the intervention of Sarah Young who pays the bill, while a young thief steals his cane. Tom attempts to salvage his fortune in the fifth print, The Marriage, by marrying a wealthy but old and ugly spinster while Sarah arrives in the background, holding their child. In The Gaming House Tom pleads for assistance in a gambling den after losing his reacquired wealth, and none present appear to notice the fire breaking out behind them.

All is lost by the seventh print, The Prison, in which Tom is incarcerated in the notorious Fleet debtor's prison, ignoring the distress of both his angry new wife and the faithful Sarah, while the beer-boy and the gaoler demand money from him. The Madhouse completes the series as Tom ends his days in Bedlam, the mental asylum, continuing to ignore Sarah who is still trying to comfort him. Fashionably-dressed women have come to the asylum to be entertained by the antics of the inmates. 

Four Times of Day, 1738
Unlike many of Hogarth's series, Four Times of Day does not depict the story of an individual. The four prints do not form a consecutive narrative, and none of the characters appear in more than one scene. Hogarth conceived of the series as 'representing in a humorous manner, morning, noon, evening and night'.

Morning
In Morning, a lady makes her way to church, shielding herself with her fan from the shocking view of two men pawing at market girls. The scene is the west side of the piazza at Covent Garden, indicated by a part of the Palladian portico of Inigo Jones's Church of St Paul visible behind Tom's Coffee House, a notorious venue celebrated in pamphlets of the time. Some revellers are ending their evening, a fight has broken out in the coffee house, causing a wig to fly out of the door. Stallholders set out their wares for the day ahead and two children, who should be making their way to school, have stopped to gaze at the market's activities.

Hogarth replicates all the features of the pastoral scene in an urban landscape. The shepherds and shepherdesses become the beggars and prostitutes, the sun overhead is replaced by the clock on the church, the snow-capped mountains become the snowy rooftops, and the Covent Garden setting with piles of fruit and vegetables echoes the country scene. 

In the centre of the picture the icy goddess of the dawn in the form of the prim churchgoer is followed by her shivering pageboy, mirroring Hesperus, the dawn bearer. The woman is the only one who seems unaffected by the cold, suggesting it may be her element. She is considered to be a hypocrite, ostentatiously attending church and carrying a fashionable ermine muff while displaying no charity to the freezing pageboy or the beggar before her.

Noon
The scene takes place in Hog Lane, part of the slum district of St Giles with the church of St Giles in the Fields in the background, as the Huguenots leave the French church. Hogarth contrasts their fussiness and high fashion with the slovenliness of the group on the other side of the road. On the left of the print a man fondles a woman, distracting her from a work, and a boy has set down his pie to rest but the plate has broken spilling the pie onto the ground where it is being rapidly consumed by an urchin. The man, woman and bawling boy fill the roles of Mars, Venus and Cupid, which would have appeared in the pastoral scenes that Hogarth is aping.

The pie shop is advertised by the head of John the Baptist on a platter and the words 'Good Eating'. The man reduced to a head on the sign, in what is assumed to be the woman's fantasy, is mirrored by the 'Good Woman' pictured on the board behind who has only her body with her head removed to create the man's ideal of female perfection.

Evening
Evening takes place slightly outside the built-up area of the city with views of rolling hills, wide evening skies, and cows at milking. The image is opressed by the heat of the summer as a pregnant woman and her husband attempt to escape from the claustrophobic city by journeying out to the fashionable Sadler's Wells Theatre, which was satirised as being frequented by tradesmen and their pretentious wives.

The husband looks harried as he carries his exhausted youngest child, while the placement of the cow's horns behind his head represent him as a cuckold and suggest that the children are not his. Behind the couple, their other children replay the scene; the father's cane protruding from the son's legs, doubling as a hobby horse, while the daughter is clearly in charge, demanding that he hand over his gingerbread.

The heat is made tangible by the flustered appearance of the woman as she fans herself, the sluggish pregnant dog that looks longingly towards the water (with an expression reflecting that of its master), and the vigorous vine growing up the side of the tavern. The family pass the New River (an artificial waterway opened in 1613 to supply fresh drinking water to London) and a tavern with a sign showing Sir Hugh Myddleton, who nearly bankrupted himself financing the scheme (a wooden pipe lies by the side of the watercourse).

Through the open window other refugees from the city can be seen sheltering from the oppressive heat in the bar. While they appear more jolly than the family group, Hogarth mocks these peope escaping to the country for fresh air only to reproduce the smoky atmosphere and crowded conditions of the city by huddling in the busy tavern with their pipes.

Night
The final picture in the series shows disorderly activities under cover of night in the Charing Cross Road (identified by the equestrian statue of Charles I and the two pubs) in an area which is now Whitehall. In the background, the passing cartload of furniture suggest tenants escaping from the landlord in a moonlight flit.

Charing Cross was a central staging post for coaches, but the congested narrow road was a frequent scene of accidents; here, a bonfire has caused the Salisbury Flying Coach to overturn. Festive bonfires were usual but risky; a house fire lights the sky in the distance; a link-boy (a boy who carried flaming torches for pedestrians at night before the introduction of street lamps) blows on his torch; street urchins are playing with fire and one of their fireworks is falling in at the coach window.

On one side of the road is a barber surgeon whose sign advertises 'Shaving, bleeding, and teeth drawn with a touch. Ecce signum!'. Inside the shop, the barber haphazardly shaves a customer holding his nose while spots of blood drip onto a cloth beneath his chin. Surgeons and barbers had been a single profession since 1540 and did not separate until 1745 when the surgeons broke away to form the Comany of Surgeons.

In the foreground a drunken freemason (identifiable by his apron and set square medallion as the Worshipful Master of a lodge) is being helped home by his Tyler (the name of the office of outer guard of a masonic lodge) as the contents of a chamber pot are emptied onto his head from a window. Pubs and brothers are all around: The Earl of Cardigan tavern is on one side of the street, and opposite is the Rummer, whose sign shows a short wide-brimmed glass of that name with a bunch of grapes on the pole, where the publican is adulterating a hogshead of wine  - Masonic lodges met in both taverns during the 1730s.

The Humours of an Election I: An Election Entertainment
The Humours of an Election comprises four prints and is one of Hogarth's Modern Moral Subjects depicting the corruption endemic in the eighteenth-century electoral process. At this time each constituency elected two MPs, and there was a property qualification for voters, so only a minority of the male population was enfranchised. There was no secret ballot, so bribery and intimidation were rife.

An inn in the fictional town of Guzzledown is the setting for the first scene, An Election Entertainment, which Hogarth displayed in his studio just days before the General Election in April 1754. It is a complex, densely populated scene full of absurdity, chaos, coercion, greed and violence. The painting depicts a tavern dinner organised by the Whig candidates, while the Tories protest outside. The Tories are carrying an antisemitic caricature of a Jew, a reference to Jewish Naturalisation Act 1753, recently passed by the Whig government. A Tory banner containing the words 'Give us our Eleven Days', a protest against the Calendar (New Style) Act 1975, is on the tavern floor.

In the tavern the two Whig candidates are ingratiating themselves with supporters. One candidate is kissing a 'conventionally unattractive woman' (read 'fat'), while a girl tries to steal his ring; another is listening to a drunken bore. At the other end of the table the mayor is collapsing from over indulgence in oysters, while the election agent is knocked out by a brick thrown through the window by the Tory mob. Other supporters throw furniture at the Tories. A banner bearing the words 'Liberty and Loyalty' stands in the corner, while outside the window the Tories carry a banner with the words 'Liberty and Property'.

In the foreground a maimed soldier sits on the floor while a patron pours gin into his head wound. Sir John Parnell, 1st Baronet is seen seated below the window, using his hand and a napkin as a puppet. The composition of the scene parodies traditional images of the Last Supper and other Biblical feasts.

Humours of an Election II: Canvassing for Votes
The second scene. Canvassing for Votes, shows individuals in the countryside to be just as avaricious and unprincipled as the crowd in the towns. There are three inns depicted, representing the electorate's three broad affiliations. The Whigs, the challengers in the 1754 Oxfordshire election, are represented by the inn furthest away. Called The Crown, it is intended to reflect the Whig's frequent association with the 'court' interest. A panel labelled 'The Excise Office', a reference to the Whig party's taxation policy and its possible joint purpose as a temporary tax office has been hung underneath the inn sign.

On the margins of the composition a soldier (right) and two old sailors (left) represent uncorrupted patriotism. The soldier peeps out from behind a now-impotently decorative figurehead depicting the British lion devouring the French fleur-de-lis. A woman sits on it looking at her bribes. The sailors on the left are re-enacting a naval victory using pieces of broken clay pipe.

Humours of an Election III: The Polling
The third scene in the series, The Polling, takes place on the day of the election and depicts the polling booth, a rough wooden construction to which all the electors are coming to publicly cast their votes. The booth is set against the backdrop of an expertly executed landscape, the background and foreground perfectly unified, the atmosphere that of an idyllic spring day, the deep blue sky, white clouds and warm sunlight caressing the group of houses and church in the middle distance and evoking a sense of calm, peace and control that is completely at odds with the scene in the foreground at the poll and background on the bridge. A woman in a carriage with a broken axle stands for Britannia. Her coachmen are gambling, ignoring the fact that the carriage is broken.

In the fourth print Chairing the Member, one of the victorious Tory candidates is being carried through the streets on a chair in a traditional ceremony. This was usually part of a day of feasting and celebration, but often an occasion for mob violence or protest if the winning candidates were considered unpopular or corrupt. He is about to be tumbled down because one of his carriers has just been accidentally hit on the head by a flail carried by a Tory-supporting rural labourer who is attempting to fight off a Whig supporter (an old sailor with a bear). 

The setting is the main street of a small market town which bridges a large stream and is almost enclosed by three buildings. Each building alludes to one of the three pillars of the state, and each is revealed to be corrupted or weakened in some way. Meanwhile, a group of frightened pigs run across the scene in a reference to the story of the Gadarene swine.

I found this sequence particularly interesting as we studied this period of history at school, and much of the primary source material came from Hogarth's paintings, engravings and prints. The layout of the artwork was very busy and a little overwhelming, so I took some images of the clutter of content with the hope of re-examining some of the items at a later date, such as the series of prints that comprise A Harlot's Progress and Marriage A-la-Mode.


Hogarth's Roundabout by Martin Rowson, 1997
Martin Rowson is a great Hogarth enthusiast and created this fine image for the 300th anniversary of Hogarth's birth. He has taken the chaos and dirt of the traffic at the Hogarth Roundabout down the road, and embellished it with extracts from Hogarth's prints.

Meanwhile, despite all this bustle of images and ideas, and the rush of the populace in the centre of London, there is still a perfect little walled garden outside the window, reminding us that, according to William Blake's 1794 poem, we can 'build a Heaven in  Hell's despair'.

Tuesday, 4 July 2023

World Press Photo Contest

On a recent trip to Sydney, we went to the World Press Photo Exhibition 2023 at the State Library of New South Wales. The annual exhibition presents the results of the 2023 World Press Photo Contest - the best and most important photojournalism and documentary photography of the last year. The winners were chosen by an independent jury that reviewed more than 60,448 photographs entered by 3,752 photographers.

 

We all know that bad news sells - few people want to read good news stories - and so it is with the photos in this exhibition. There are harrowing images of war, floods, drought, poverty, incarceration, and ecological disasters, leading to a warning such as the one above, and the one below: the photo of the year.

Mariupol Maternity Hospital Airstrike by Evgeniy Malolekta

Iryna Kalinina (32), an injured pregnant woman, is carried from a maternity hospital that was damaged during a Russian airstrike in Mariupol, Ukraine, on 9 March 2022. Her baby, named Miron (after the word for 'peace') was stillborn, and half an hour later Iryna died as well. An OSCE report concluded the hospital was deliberately targeted by Russia, resulting in three deaths and some 17 injuries. The jury felt the photo depicted an attack on the future of Ukraine. Evgeniy Maloletka photographed the image on assignment for Associated Press.

The port of Mariupol on the Sea of Azov was the first city struck when Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022. Civilians were hit hard. 

The strategically important port is one of the largest Russian-0speaking cities in Ukraine, a major industrial hub, and vital for the country's steel exports. The territory was also of symbolic value to invading forces as it represented a large step towards building a land bridge between the self-proclaimed Donetsk People's Republic (DNR) and Crimea, which Russia had illegally annexed in 2014.

Images from The Siege of Mariupol by Evgeniy Maloletka

Top: 06 March 2022 - Zhanna Goma (right) and her neighbours settle in a bomb shelter in Mariupol, Ukraine.

Middle left: 11 March 2022 - Serhiy Kralya, a civilian injured during shelling by Russian forces, rests after surgery at a hospital in Mariupol, Ukraine.

Middle right: 11 March 2022 - Russian army tanks move through a street on the outskirts of Mariupol. The Z marking is one of several symbols painted on Russian military vehicles in the early stages of the invasion. 

Bottom left: 04 March 2022 - Marina Yatsko and her boyfriend Olesksandr Kulahin bring her 18-moth son Kirill, fatally wounded during shelling, to a hospital in Mariupol, Ukraine.

Bottom right: 09 March 2022 - People place dead bodies in a mass grave in an old cemetery in Mariupol. According to the BBC, on some days during periods of heavy Russian shelling, up to 150 people a day were buried in mass graves. 

By early March, Russian forces had completely surrounded the city, restricting water, power and food supplies. Some 200,000 citizens were trapped in Mariupol, as attempts to evacuate them failed. Russian bombardment devastated the city, and included civilian targets such as a maternity hospital and a theatre where people were sheltering. Evgeniy Maloletka, who is Ukrainian, was one of very few photographers documenting events in Mariupol at that time. 

Image from The Siege of Mariupol by Evgeniy Malolekta

On 21 April, President Vladimir Putin announced that Russian forces had taken Mariupol, but the city council said that 1,000 civilians alongside thousands of Ukrainian soldiers were holding out in the giant Azovstal steelworks. By 20 May, the soldiers defending the steelworks had surrendered, and the UN and Red Cross were able to evacuate the citizens. The UN Human Rights Office confirmed 1,348 civilian deaths during the siege of Mariupol, stating that the actual death toll was likely thousands higher: Ukraine says that figure is more than 25,000.

At the time of this exhibition in April 2023, Mariupol remained under Russian occupation. Russia has begun rebuilding the city and scrubbing it of its Ukrainian identity by renaming streets and changing school curriculums. 

The exhibition includes a short history of World Press Photo: since 1955, World Press Photo has connected the world to the stories that matter. The non-profit organisation remains committed to press freedom and the power of visual journalism by providing platforms that present accurate, diverse, and trustworthy images. 

  • 1955 - A group of Dutch photographers organizes the first World Press Photo contest to introduce their work to a global audience
  • 1967 -Although black-and-white pictures still dominate the submissions, and chromogenic printing remains expensive, the jury awards World Press Photo of the Year to a colour photograph for the first time 
  • 1972 - The annual exhibition featuring current winners of the World Press Photo contest begins to tour outside the Netherlands. Since then, the exhibition has travelled to 129 countries
  • 1977 - Francoise Demulder becomes the first woman whose work is awarded World Press Photo of the Year
  • 1990 Charlie Cole's photograph of a demonstrator in front of tanks in Tiananmen Square becomes a symbol of peaceful resistance. To this day, this picture remains banned in China
Tank Man, Tiananmen Square by Charlie Cole
  • 2002 - Fourteen years after creation of the JPEG, digital entries surpass analogue entries for the first time in the history of the contest
  • 2019 - John Moore's photograph of a child from Honduras at the US border, which wins World Press Photo of the Year, leads to the repeal of the 'Zero Tolerance' policy that permitted separating immigrant parents from their children when apprehended
  • 2021- To better represent a plurality of perspectives and global voices, World Press Photo introduces a new regional strategy, changing the set-up of the annual contest, the categories, and the judging
2022 World Press Photo of the Year by Amber Bracken
  • 2022 - With her photograph of a roadside memorial commemorating the deaths of indigenous children who attended the Kamloops Indian Residential School in Canada, Amber Bracken becomes the first person to win World Press Photo of the Year without depicting a human figure

Woman, Life, Freedom

This photo-based video project narrates one chaotic night in the life of an Iranian nurse as she saves the life of a young protestor called Reza. The footage offers a rare glimpse into the dangers faced by protestors on the streets of Iran today, situated in the context of an inciting incident: on 16 September 2022, Mahsa 'Jina' Amini, a 22-year-old Kurdish woman, died after she was arrested by the Islamic Republic's morality police for allegedly violation the country's strict rules restricting the dress and conduct of women. The ensuing protests quickly intensified, spreading across the country. The Islamic Republic responded by disrupting internet access and violently repressing uprisings. Because hospitals are controlled by the regime, anyone injured in the protests risks arrest and further abuse upon seeking medical attention. 

Iranian photographer Hossein Fatemi encountered the nurse in the video while providing support to local Iranian photographers covering the protests. Images and video for this project were captured by local photojournalists, the nurse herself, and a photographer on assignment to cover her story. Journalists and photographers attempting to report on the protests face reprisals from the Iranian regime, ranging from intimidation to arrest and violent abuse. Due to these efforts, it is difficult to know what is really happening inside the country. Many of the photographers who captured the images seen here will remain anonymous for security reasons. 

Images from The Price of Peace in Afghanistan by Mads Nissen

These two images are from a collection that won World Press Photo Story of the Year, which captures the daily life of people living across Afghanistan in 2022. The top image shows Khalil Ahmad (15), whose parents, unable to afford food for the family, decided to sell his kidney for US$3,500. After the operation, Khalil suffers chronic pain and no longer has the strength for football and cricket. The lack of jobs and the threat of starvation has led to a dramatic increase in the illegal organ trade. 

The bottom image shows women and children begging for bread outside a bakery in central Kabul, Afghanistan. Bread is a staple in Afghanistan, but soaring prices have forced more and more people to rely entirely on the compassion of others. 

In August 2021, the withdrawal of US and allied forces from Afghanistan marked the end of a 20-year long attempt at nation-building. Taliban forces, having sustained an insurgency across the country, returned to power shortly after the collapse of the Afghan state. Consequently, all international aid, which in 2019 accounted for an estimated 80 percent of the country's expenditures, was halted, and 7 to 9 billion dollars of assets belonging to the Afghan state were frozen. Without these two sources of government income, the already fragile Afghan economy effectively collapsed.

National gross domestic product of Afghanistan dropped to around 25 percent of its peak in early 2021. Estimates for 2022 suggest that 97 percent of the population lives below the poverty line and 95 percent of people do not have enough to eat. Nine million people are at risk of famine and, according to the UN, over a million children are severely malnourished. COVID-19, intense droughts, and the inability of aid organisations to bring relief to those in need have all exacerbated the crisis, which is only expected to worsen in 2023.

The Nomad's Final Journey by Jonathan Fontaine 

This highly-commended image shows Samira (16) looking out onto Qolodo camp near Gode in the Somali Region, Ethiopia, on 16 May 2022. Her family owned 45 goats and 10 camels, all of which died during recent droughts.

Nomadic peoples of Ethiopia and Somalia depend on their livestock, migrating across their territory to pasture their animals. In recent years water scarcity has threatened these livestock. Exacerbated by the climate crisis, droughts have devastated the region which, according to the World Food Program, now endanger the food security of over 26 million people. With many families forced to seek aid in climate refugee camps, social structures are weakening, precipitating violence against women and a host of mental health crises.

As droughts persist annually, women, who are often responsible for finding water, bear an enormous share of the physical and mental toll exacted by the ongoing crisis. 


The text in the image above reads: This map, generated by RSF (Reporters Sans Frontiers) represents the current state of press freedom in 180 countries and territories. To arrive at the results compiled and visualised here RSF conducted extensive research during the past calendar year. In addition to distributing questionnaires among journalists, RSF also employed a panel of experts who ranked press freedom around the world according to five equally-weighted criteria: political context, legal framework, economic context, sociocultural context and safety. Their rankings are coded by colour, with the highest level of press freedom classified as 'good situation'. As you can see, that's pretty much Scandinavia. And that's it. 

Part of Me by Nadia Shira Cohen

Surrogate mothers Vin Win (right) and Ry Ly (left) were arrested during a raid to fight trafficking in 2018. They live near one another and their children from surrogacy, Korng (3, left) and Phavit (4, right) often play together. Vin Win is separated from her husband who resents the situation.

This series portrays Cambodian surrogate mothers who have been required to raise their surrogate children as their own ever since Cambodia began prosecuting surrogacy in 2016. 

Surrogacy - the act of carrying and birthing a baby for another person or couple - was accepted in practice in Cambodia until 2016, when the government started prosecuting surrogate mothers under already existing human trafficking laws. In 2018, a raid on a house in Phnom Penh led to the arrest and imprisonment of 32 women who were acting as surrogates to predominantly Chinese parents. Nearly all gave birth in confinement and, after sentencing by the Cambodian Supreme Court, all were obliged to raise the babies themselves or face prison terms. 

Many of the women sought surrogacy arrangements with Chinese family planning agencies in order to help their families escape impoverishment and, in some instances, indebtedness from microfinance loans. In recent years, Cambodian households have become some of the most indebted on Earth and a major contributing factor has been the poorly regulated microfinancing sector. The rising burden of financial debt has resulted in an increase in child labour and families forced to sell their homes and land. For many of the women portrayed in this series, surrogacy represented a way out of debt, but now with the court ruling against them, their lives have become more difficult. Despite financial, social, and personal challenges, many of the would-be surrogate mothers have formed a deep bond with their children even as they express sadness that their children will not be able to benefit from the economic advantages that their biological parents could provide. 

Death of a Nation by Kimberly dela Cruz

Winner of the long-term projects in the Southeast Asia and Oceania category, this project documents the Philippines' drugs offensive from its outset, capturing its broadening focus and the continued impact on families involved. The above photograph shows Jazmine Durana (15) cradling her month-old daughter Hazel on 2 February 2017, at the wake of her partner John 'Toto' Dela Cruz (16), who was shot by men wearing black masks a few days earlier.

Soon after taking office in June 2016, Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte began a concerted 'war on drugs', repeatedly ordering attacks against suspects. A surge of extrajudicial killings followed, perpetrated not only by police but also by masked vigilantes and other civilians. Amnesty International reports that executions mostly target low-income communities. The Philippine National Police admits to more than 6,000 such deaths to date; local human rights organisations put the figure at 30,000. The police appear to act with impunity, with only a handful of these killings being seriously investigated and almost no prosecutions. 

Images from Death of a Nation

Top left: November 01, 2016 - Neighbours survey the crime scene hours after masked men massacred Manuel Evangelista, Admar Velarde, Paulo Tuboro, Jennifer Discargar, and Catalino Algueles, in Mandaluyong, the Philippines.

Top Right: 04 January 2017 - AJ (16) mourns at the scene where unidentified assailants have shot his neighbour Antonio Perez outside his home in Pasay City, the Philippines.

Bottom left: March 04, 2017 - the body of Kristita Padual lies at the crime scene, after unidentified murderers killed her and Ernesto Moritz while they were having dinner beside the road, in Quezon City, the Philippines.

Bottom right: December 09, 2016 - Men shield their faces from the media after being arrested in a food factory that the police claimed to be a drug den, in Pandacan, Manila, the Philippines.

According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, the Philippines has a low prevalence of drug use compared to the global average. Human rights organisations such as the World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT) and Amnesty International say killings often target political opponents, activists or marginalised groups. A Human Rights Watch report found that many of the killings that police attributed to drug gangs to be a veneer to shield themselves from culpability for executions carried out without legal process - an accusation the police refute, claiming self-defense.

Images from Death of a Nation

Top left: 08 September 2019 - Nestor and Alma watch the evening news, in Quezon City, the Philippines. Exactly three years earlier, their son Richard was killed during a police operation - an event that was reported on the news at the time.

Top right: 21 February 2022 - The family of Rovelyn and Richard Cham receive the urns containing their ashes in Tayuman, Manila, the Philippines. Unknown gunmen killed the couple at home in 2016.

Bottom left: 22 November 2019 - Mothers and widows of war-on-drugs victims rehearse for a theatre performance in Tondo, Manilla, the Philippines. Sarah Celiz (centre) lost two of her sons in 2016 and 2017 and was left to care for her 12 grandchildren. The performance was organised by Paghilom (Healing), a program started in 2016 by former drug user Father Flaviano Villanueva for the families of victims of the war on drugs, providing them with support and counseling.

Bottom right: 14 February 2022 - Mary Anne Domingo stands outside a courthouse after giving testimony, in Caloocan, the Philippines. She brought a case against the police after her husband and son were killed in a raid in 2016. The trial commenced in 2021.

In 2020, Fatou Bensouda, then the prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, said there was a 'reasonable basis to believe' that crimes against humanity had been committed in the Philippines in connection with President Duterte's drugs offensive. In July 2022, Duterte's successor President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. announced a refocus of the anti-drug offensive onto rehabilitation, however, killings continue and reforms have not yet been made to rehabilitation programs, according to Human Rights Watch. 

The photographer has been documenting the war on drugs since its outset, and the jury commended her ability to capture the continued impact on families involved. 

The Dying River by Jonas Kako (winner of the North and Central America, Singles category)

Alfredo, Ubaldo, and Jose tend beehives near Wenden in the Arizona desert, United States. A substantial decrease in rainfall in the area means that the men must now provide water for the bees in troughs. Heat and drought weakens bees, making them more susceptible to pathogens and parasites, and impacts the pants from which they feed. Between 2019 and 2020, colonies of managed honey-bees declined by 43.7% across the US. Bees are vital for pollinating many crops, and so play an important role in food security for humans. 

This image is part of a broader project on how the climate crisis and increasing water demand are affecting the Colorado River, which flows nearby. Annual flow in the Colorado River has shrunk 20 percent in the past 30 years, according to a river program manager. The Colorado relies on snow melt from the Rocky Mountains and precipitation in upstream forests that collects in lakes and natural reservoirs. Drought and global heating have accelerated evaporation from reservoirs, and melted snowpack faster, so that rivers run dry earlier in the season. Hot, dry conditions have also parched the soil, which soaks up precipitation before it even reaches the river.  

Water diverted for agriculture accounts for up to 80 percent of consumption in the Colorado River Basin, and a series of dams along the course of the river - providing drinking water to more than 40 million people and hydroelectric power to meet the needs of some seven million - further shrinks the flow.

In late 2022, the US government implemented severe restrictions on river-water use in states along the course of the Colorado River, cutting Arizona's annual allocation by 21 percent.

Jury comment: This portrait of beekeepers is visually clean and sparks interest and curiosity to understand the issue at hand. The image is subtle and understated, and the jury was impressed by the composition of bees across all thirds. While the topic resonates at ag global level, the image itself encourages us to sit with these particular people and consider how they might be impacted by the ongoing environmental crisis.

Oil Spill in Lima by Musuk Nolte

On 15 January, nearly 12,000 barrels of crude oil spilled into the sea while a tanker was unloading at Repsol's La Pampilla refinery. Repsol, the Peruvian government, and the Italian tanker company each disputed the cause of the spillage, trading accusations of negligence, inadequacy of equipment, and mismanagement. 

The spill extended over 7.13 square kilometres, polluting beaches, killing wildlife, and impacting livelihoods in what the Peruvian government termed the country's worst ecological disaster in recent memory. 

The oil reached three marine protected areas: Lomas de Ancon, the Pescadores Islets, and Punta Salina. The plankton-rich Peruvian Pacific waters sustain a chain of marine life, from anchovies to dolphins and seabirds. Marine mammals and birds are especially vulnerable, as the oil affects their eyes, nasal tissue and their insulating capacity, potentially leading to suffocation and hypothermia. Commercial fisheries, people relying on tourism, and local communities dependent on seafood for their diets also suffered. UN experts believe the effects of the spill will last up to ten years.
 
Alpaqueros by Alessandro Cinque

Vital to the livelihoods of many people in the Peruvian Andes, alpacas face new challenges due to the climate crisis. Part of the camelid family, alpacas can endure the high altitudes of the Andes and are a critical source of income for farmers in an environment where few or no crops can be cultivated. They are primarily bred for their fine fibre (wool) which is highly prized for knitwear and woven cloth. Tens of thousands of Andean families depend on raising alpacas or dealing in their fibre for subsistence. Among local Indigenous communities such as the Quechia, alpacas are also embedded in cultural and ritual life.

The climate crisis is putting alpacas and the communities they sustain at risk. Shorter rainy seasons and more intense, longer periods of drought are shrinking natural pastures and reducing the quality of the grass on which alpacas feed. In addition, meltwater from Peru's glaciers, which supports high meadows during the long dry season, is declining rapidly. Peruvian glaciers retreated by 53 percent between 1962 and 2016. 

These challenges threaten not only the alpacas, but the loss of high-Andean cultural identity, as alpaquero (alpaca-farmer) communities are forced to move to even greater altitudes, or to abandon their lifestyles entirely and seek work in low-lying cities. Scientists hope to help address the problem using biotechnology to create alpaca breeds more resistant to extremes in temperature. This would help the animals to survive harsh nights at higher altitudes, as well as thrive at lower elevations, since alpacas also suffer in warmer temperatures, from illnesses not present in highland areas.

It's fair to say that the images and the situations depicted are extremely grim. A brief summary of the Year in Review attempts to explain 'What Happened in 2022?' "Photojournalists working in 2022 brought stories of the war in Ukraine and life under Taliban rule in Afghanistan, of use and abuse of river water in Central Asia and the United States, flooding in Australia, oil spillage in Peru, and people with dementia in Ghana. But a tough judging process and the limitations of how to visualise certain stories means that some major stories discussed by the jury did not make it through to the final selection:
  1. Anti-LGBTQI+ Violence - April 2022, Kenya - Sheila Adhiambo Lumumba, a non-binary lesbian, is found raped murdered in Karatina, Kenya. Human rights organisations call attention to institutionalised homophobia in Kenya and other nations across the continent including Ghana, Nigeria and Uganda.
  2. Uvalde School Shooting - May 2022, Uvalde, Texas, United States - On 24 May and 18-year-old gunman kills 19 children and two teachers at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, in the deadliest school shooting in the US in a decade. 
  3. Abortion Law Overturned - June 2022, United States - The US Supreme Court overturns Roc v Wade, the legislation that made access to an abortion a federal right in the United States. The move leads to nationwide protests.
  4. Sri Lankan President Resigns - July 2022, Sri Lanka - President Gotabaya Rajapaksa flees the country and resigns, after months of protest against the country's economic crisis had culminated in popular occupation of the presidential palace.
  5. Death of Mahsa Amini - September 2022, Iran - The death of Mahsa Amini after being arrested by Iran's 'morality police' for allegedly not wearing the hijab in accordance with regulations sparked some of the largest demonstrations in Iran in years.
  6. Kanjuruhan Stadium Disaster - October 2022, Jawa Timur, Indonesia - More than 130 football fans die in a crush apparently sparked by police firing tear gas as a crowd-control measure, while leaving the Kanjuruhan Stadium after a match, in one of the world's worst stadium disasters. 
  7. 'Lula' Wins Brazilian Presidential Elections - October/ November 2022, Brazil - Luiz Lula da Silva wins a majority in the Brazilian presidential elections. Former president Jair Bolsonaro does not initially concede defeat, but President Lula da Silva is inaugurates in January 2023.
  8. Ethiopia and TPLF Declare Truce - November 2022, Ethiopia - Ethiopia's federal government and the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF), which controlled much of Tigray province, agree to stop fighting after a two-year conflict that has caused a dire humanitarian crisis.
  9. White Paper Protests - November/ December 2022, China - Protests spread through cities across China, as demonstrators held up blank sheets of paper to oppose on-going government COVID-19 restrictions. In January 2023 China revoked its Zero-COVID policy. 
An image from Net-Zero Transition by Simone Tramonte

In the above image (13 July 2021), people swim at Amager Strand, Denmark, near a wind farm which is co-owned by 8,552 electricity consumers, and serves more than 40,000 Copenhagen households. Upwards of 15,000 Danish families are members of similar wind turbine co-operatives. 

Winner of the Europe, Long-term projects category, this sequence is a rare positive view of the world around us, which is why I felt the need to include it in this post. The project documents different technologies that offer possible routes of transition to a net-zero economy. The photographer visited innovative facilities across Europe, from Iceland to Italy, from 2020 to 2022. 

Human-induced climate change is the largest, most pervasive threat to the natural environment and society that the world has ever experienced, according to the UN Human Rights Office, OHCHR. This prompted the European Union to establish targets to cut greenhouse emissions by at least 55 percent by 2030. European companies seeking ways to achieve these goals are exploring renewable energies, new technologies for food production, and the circular economy as potential ways forward. 

Image from the series World Champions by Tomàs Francisco Cuesta

I wanted to finish this on a positive note, which is why I have placed this image last. It is a scene of jubilation as Argentinians revel in their country's return to World Cup dominance, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 18 December 2022. An estimated five million people took to the streets to participate in the parade and join the national team members in one of the greatest public demonstrations in Argentina's history. For striker and star player Lionel Messi the win cements his legacy as one of the greatest footballers of all time.  Argentinian photographer Tomàs Francisco Cuesta said about taking these photographs,
"You really just feel good looking at those images, and those are ones that may resonate. It's just the beauty of sports. And it's the beauty of imagery, the beauty of pictures. Soccer in Argentina is so much more than a sport. It's more important than Christmas, more important than the New Years. For many people, it's more important than their jobs. That's why you saw five million people crowding the streets of Buenos Aires. It was the first time that I saw such a union in the streets without any discrimination. People were really united to celebrate and to let the players know that they were supporting them."